DAY EIGHT

 This is truth


 

IX. Confessional status

Our committee was asked to evaluate “whether or not, with respect to same-sex behavior

and other issues identified in the study, it will be advisable for future synods to consider . . .

declaring a status confessionis” (Acts of Synod 2016, p. 920). To raise the question of status

confessionis, which means “confessional status,” is to wonder whether some teaching or

ecclesiastical practice, if adopted, would contradict the teachings of the confessions of the

church. To put it another way, is it a violation of our confessions to teach that it is acceptable for

Christians to use pornography or to engage in premarital sex, extramarital sex, or homosexual

activity?

 

Heidelberg Catechism Q&A 108, which explains the meaning of the seventh

commandment (“You shall not commit adultery”) states that “God condemns all unchastity, and

that therefore we should thoroughly detest it and live decent and chaste lives, within or outside

of the holy state of marriage.” By the word “unchastity” the catechism intends to encompass all

sexual immorality, including homosexual activity. Ursinus, one of the authors of the Heidelberg

Catechism, confirms this in his commentary on Q&A 108. He writes that the first class of lusts

included in unchastity “are those which are contrary to nature and from the devil. . . . The lusts

of which the apostle Paul speaks in the first chapter of his Epistle to the Romans are of this

class, as the confounding of sexes, [and] also abuses of the female sex.” Ursinus goes on to

say that unchastity includes incest as well, even though this sin is not mentioned in the

catechism by name (Zacharias Ursinus, Commentary on the Heidelberg Catechism, p. 1043).

Therefore, pornography, polyamory, and all forms of premarital and extramarital sex as well as

homosexual sex are encompassed in the catechism’s condemnation of unchastity.

 

We conclude, therefore, that the church’s teaching on premarital sex, extramarital sex,

adultery, polyamory, pornography, and homosexual sex already has confessional status. As

such, there is no need for a new declaration. We also conclude that this status is warranted

because these sins threaten a person’s salvation. The Scriptures call the church to warn people

to flee sexual immorality for the sake of their souls and to encourage them with God’s presence

and power to equip them for holy living. A church that fails to call people to repentance and offer

them the hope of God’s loving deliverance is acting like a false church.

 

In coming to this conclusion, we observe that we stand with the majority church worldwide,

including the Roman Catholic Church, all branches of Orthodoxy, the non-Western global

church, and a majority of active Protestants in North America and Europe. Indeed, the global

church finds the Western church’s challenges to biblical teaching on human sexuality

incomprehensible and offensive. To refuse to uphold Christian teaching on sexual immorality

would signal that the Christian Reformed Church in North America is deviating not only from

Scripture but from the shared confession of the historic and worldwide church.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Committee to Articulate a Foundation–laying

Biblical Theology of Human Sexuality



Comments